Exposing myself as a feminist gamer
For the vast majority of my life I was the only ladytype in a social group full of men because my hobbies were those considered by the western world to be traditionally masculine: I loved working on cars, playing football, the nutritional science of beer, live blues and metal, and, most especially for our purposes, any and all gaming. Like, I had a vast and profound collection of Activision patches and twice-weekly tabletop groups, gaming was such an important part of my life. And all through that time, I was one of The Good Chicks. You know the ones: just one of the guys, lolololol sandwich jokes, bitches be trippin amirite, etc etc.
My male-majority social groups were so important to me when I was a kid (and by “kid” please understand that I mean from my weester gamerhood through college and young adulthood) that I spent a lot of time pulling what Melissa McEwan calls the terrible bargain: even when someone said something shitty I wouldn’t call it out, because I couldn’t; saying something would cause a big fuss, my friends would all get mad at me and upset about it, and it would ruin the whole day. So I convinced myself that I was just being crazypants hysterically oversensitive since obviously no one ever meant anything by it, and I sucked it up and moved on.
This happens a lot, even now. All the time.
Here’s the thing: lots of people I care about say shitty things, including me! Lots of people in the world do this, sometimes because they don’t know any better — and they don’t know any better because we are conditioned to strike the terrible bargain every time, so they so rarely hear that these uncool things are hurtful and should be stopped.
So there is some background: keeping my uncomfortableness to myself, swallowing concerns, and of course stridently insisting that I was certainly not a feminist, not like one of those women. Lots of things happened to evolve my feelings and actions on the matter, but there was one seriously majorbig turning point: I had a daughter.
The second I learned that my fetus was genetically female I started looking at the world a different way, and that was when I stopped putting up with so much bullshit. I very clearly remember when the world clicked into place for me: Mr. Aro and I went to a particular big-box store to sign up for the baby registry, and I saw that the toy aisles were divided into “Boys” and “Girls.” Not the subtle way you’re thinking, either, where one aisle is pink and one is blue, but ACTUAL LITERAL SIGNAGE: this toy is for a boy (action figures, video games, motherfucking legos), and that toy is for a girl (fashion dolls, dress-up costumes, play kitchens), period the end.
To say that I flipped out would be something of an understatement. I think there is maybe still a smoking crater where that store used to be.
What the fuck kind of world did I bring my daughter into? A world where just saying that she wants to think critically within Traditionally Dude Pursuits gets her the most horrifying hatespeech imaginable. And that’s my world, too, and I have a responsibility not just as a parent but as a member of the global community to make it better. Because this shit? This shit where we have to get all rapey mcbeaterson on weester Lara Croft so gameplaying dudes can relate to protecting her? This shit needs to stop, and the only way it will stop is if people keep speaking out and telling everyone that it’s not okay.
No one is denying that it’s hard. I have to check myself and my privileges and my language every goddamn day. It’s so scary to take that deep breath and tell someone you care about that what they’ve said or done is uncool and run the risk of setting off the Privilege Phalanx to stab you right in the RAEG!1. It’s especially scary to do so within the gaming culture where you not only have to worry about the reaction of the person(s) to whom you direct your uncoolness doctrine, but also the reaction of every other person on the internet.
For some people, that worry makes speaking up not worthwhile, and that’s so sad. I used to be one of them (and this ties back into the geek social fallacies), and so I understand the reasons that can go into making that choice to keep quiet and shake it off whenever and however you can. I understand that in many cases you are literally exposing yourself — to threats, to harassment, to eviction from your social group, to a whole passel of shit that sucks. I understand. I really, really do.
The problem I have is that this existence is not sustainable. “It’s the internet, that’s how it works” is not sustainable. “Trash-talk is part of the culture” is not sustainable. “Straight white dudes get harassed too” is not sustainable. “But telling people to quit being douchebags is censorship” is not sustainable.
The world I want to give my daughter (and your daughters and your sons and everyone else) is not that world. I want to give her a world where thinking critically about social issues in games is a discussion method, not a one-way ticket to hateytown. Where she plays Cooking Mama because she wants to, not because that’s A Game Girls Play. Where, if she works in a computer shop, people don’t immediately assume she’s the receptionist. Where “but sex sells” is not a common retort to complaints against sexualized violence.
And that’s why I’m a gamer and a feminist and a feminist gamer, openly and proudly, though it’s lost me friends in the past: because I’m building that world. It is constantly filthy and backbreaking work, but I promise that it’s worth it.

My name is Liore, and I am also a feminist gamer. (Hi Liore!)
No, seriously, great post. I was very fortunate to have a feminist mother. I remember her telling me when I was 13 or so that in her mind the difference between men and women was socialization more than nature, and I was all, "You're crazy, lady, girls are born girly and love ponies!" At the time I didn't appreciate the framework she gave me, but it certainly came into play a few years later when I was ready to think about this stuff as a young adult.
I always identified as a feminist, but it's only the last few years that I've gotten more into feminist thought and frankly that happened because of video games and the people I've met and situations I've seen. And being more aware of feminist thought and social justice in general has made me a better person. I'm better at critical thinking, I'm better at empathy and accepting the opinions of others, I'm much more understanding of women in general (I certainly had a dash of "I don't get along with women" in me a few years ago), and amusingly enough I'm way more comfortable with sex and overt sexuality from myself or those around me now that I have better tools to express where those fit within a patriarchy. And it's still work, to keep thinking and growing, all the time.
I don't know what my point is. I guess it's just, "fight on, sister". I'm never going to have kids, but I will feel good knowing that I did my part to make things better for your daughter and all those like her.
My recent post Swimming Against the Tide of Popular Opinion
That's a big thing for me, too — how thinking critically about pop culture has made me a better person and honestly I think a better parent. So much of the furor around recent incidents specifically has been about how that's just how things are and it can't ever possibly change, and I just absolutely can't think that way. It HAS to change, even if I have to personally unleash SRS! MOM! FACE! on every single member of 4chan, because otherwise I'll have failed my own personal tiny human and that's just not an acceptable outcome.
Aww there's something in my eye. <3
I can very much identify with a lot of what you said. I still struggle with talking about my feminism in meatspace simply because a lot of my friends are sincerely good people – they just don't engage with the same geeky things as me. In gaming terms, I've been pretty lucky – I grew up playing them as an only child so they were never a particularly gendered or group experience for me until I encountered nerds in Secondary School who also played the same stuff and happened to be boys.
I was very much a 'ladette' for a number of years. These days I'm much more at ease with myself and thus have been in a position to help create gaming environments that I am happy in (such as being able to set the tone and atmosphere in my WoW guild).
That said it can still be tough, although I didn't have such a watershed moment as you. My feminism emerged gradually after being exposed to it on livejournal, so I grappled with learning the jargon and the concepts for a long time before I chose to join in with any discussion.
Seriously great post (and a great blog in general).
My recent post [MMOs] When is a digital world a soulless world?
God, yes, I constantly struggle with it in meatspace, not least because I'm a female programmer. My current office is mmmmmostly comfortable with occasional outliers, but I've spent more of my professional life in toxic environments than not — and speaking up in a work situation is even harder, because that's your livelihood you're risking, not just your social and emotional well-being.
That's why it absolutely blows my mind and sends me 'round the bend when people insist that there's no such thing as sexism anymore. Like, seriously, how unobservant do you have to be? Ugggh.
Also, I love "ladette." I mean that's awful, but it's hilarious. XD
I knew there was a reason I kept reading your blog! Funny, intelligent, feminist…it's important to me that bloggers openly identify as feminist, especially when they are amazing people, because I want to eradicate that stupid stereotype of the humorless feminist ><
I had a similar childhood nerdy lady-hate thing going on, where being one of the boys was super important and I figured the best way to show my uniqueness was to eschew all things feminine. It took me a long time to realize what it was and why I was thinking it.
So yeah, feminist solidarity! I'll keep speaking up because I want your daughter and all little girls and boys to grow up without sexism that limits who they can be!
My recent post SALTY
A thing that blows my mind is how often dudes don't realize that sexism hurts them, too. The trashtalk they get is almost entirely female-gendered, they get mocked for behaving in "girly" ways or having "girly" interests — it all fits together as parts of the same whole.
One of the wonderful things about gamerspace on the internet is that it finally made me confront a lot of my internalized hatred for women (I'm just one of the guys!), as well as some of my distrust of men (Guys are for cool stuff, not talkin' about feelings!) It's funny how a space can be simultaneously such a harmful, scary place as well as such a place for friendship and growth.
This is a great post, thanks for sharing it Aro. :)
That crazy dichotomy is what gets me. "Hooray, a place where I belong! … And in order to belong I need to make sure I never step a toe out of line or speak up about anything ever!" The internalized woman-hatred was a problem for me for so long — especially like Liore says with the slut v. nice girl dynamic. The gaming community is so strange, like its own little microcosm.
[...] “Exposing myself as a feminist gamer”, by Arolaide * “Arkham City’s Weird Bitch Fixation” (Kotaku) * “Do I really want to be a [...]
[...] “Exposing myself as a feminist gamer”, by Arolaide * “Arkham City’s Weird Bitch Fixation” (Kotaku) * “Do I really want to be a [...]